• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Shy's Pizza Connection

At Shy's Pizza Connection, we believe in forging connections through exceptional food and shared experiences. Nestled in Prosser, WA, our pizzeria is dedicated to serving up handcrafted pizzas that cater to every palate, including a variety of vegetarian options. We provide a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for families and groups, with amenities such as outdoor seating and bike parking. Our commitment to quality extends beyond our pizza; with options for takeout and delivery, we ensure every meal is both convenient and satisfying. Join us at Shy's Pizza Connection and discover the taste of community and love in every slice.

Shy's Pizza Connection: Reviews & Ratings

Ben B
Ben B

This is a true Prosser Pizza institution. Before the cheap national chain pizzas came to town, this is where you came with the team after games and played the arcade games. The pizza is has a somewhat thinner crust, traditional red sauce ...

Mary Mejia
Mary Mejia

Unfortunately Shys is pick up only. I live in Benton City and this is the only pizza that we get. The owners are wonderful and friendly and I always enjoy seeing them.

Kelly & Monica Wentz
Kelly & Monica Wentz

We are so glad we called! We are staying at Wine County RV park and they deliver here. The lady on the phone was very up front about the delivery time and they were actually early. The toppings are fresh and the crust is delicious. The delivery man was very nice and we will definitely order again when we come back in the spring.

Kate Page
Kate Page

Super friendly staff, fairly prompt service. Stray kittens outside! Very cute. Got Jojos tasty! and meat free taco pizza very accommodating!. Good ranch.

Hazel edwards
Hazel edwards

I came from Tricities and always remembered as a kiddo this was THE spot to be after sports or with family. I traveled through Prosser as soon as I opened the door to Shys Pizza I was welcomed with a hello! 25 for medium cheese pizza and breadsticks with ranch of course. Delicious, affordable, welcoming!

A May
A May

I wish I could rate more than just 5 stars!! Ive been desperately seeking a pizza with EXTRA cheese because Im tired of paying for extra cheese elsewhere and being disappointed. This was our first time trying Shys and they HOOKED.ME.UP on the cheese!! Thank you! Plus your pizzas looked beautiful and yall were super nice!!

Jade V
Jade V

One of my favorite treats. Husband and I love the broasted chicken meals they offer. I love being able to call in an order and just step in and pick up. The staff are always so pleasant and happy to help. A wonderful pizza place to kick back and enjoy anytime of day

Gisel Sandoval
Gisel Sandoval

My favorite thus far my go to medium Hawaiian with olives and 2 ranch and its ...

Location

Welcome to the culinary delight that is Shy's Pizza Connection, a vibrant oasis for pizza lovers nestled in the heart of Prosser, WA. This unclaimed gem is more than just a pizza joint; it's a community gathering place where flavors dance on your palate and every meal is a celebration.

Shy's Pizza Connection boasts an impressive array of offerings that cater to every appetite. From the moment you walk through the doors at 1306 Meade Ave, you feel the cozy atmosphere envelop you. The moderate noise level enhances the experience, making it perfect for convivial gatherings with friends or family. Kids are welcome, and outdoor seating provides a charming option for those who enjoy dining al fresco.

One of the standout features is the extensive menu that includes many vegetarian options, ensuring that everyone—from avid meat lovers to devoted herbivores—leaves satisfied. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni or a unique veggie delight, there’s something to tantalize every taste bud. Remember, all dishes are available for delivery or takeout, making it convenient to enjoy your favorites from the comfort of your home.

  • Location: 1306 Meade Ave, Prosser, WA 99350, United States
  • Phone: (509) 786-4095
  • Reservations: Accepted
  • Payment: Credit cards welcome
  • Group Friendly: Perfect for larger gatherings
  • Accessibility: Bike parking available
  • Entertainment: TV for sports and events

The experience at Shy’s transcends beyond just food; it’s an engagement with the community. The friendly staff serves not only dishes but also warmth and hospitality, making every visit memorable. The outdoor seating area adds a picturesque touch for those looking to unwind while enjoying their meal. As a food reviewer, I felt truly delighted by the care that goes into every slice. The flavors speak to the passion behind this establishment, making Shy's not just a meal, but an experience.

If you find yourself in the neighborhood, don’t miss the chance to indulge at Shy’s Pizza Connection. It’s more than just pizza; it’s where connections are made over great food.